McDonald’s withdraws appeal to build controversial restaurant in Great Barr

The proposals to develop Buffet Island on Queslett Road, Great Barr, first put forward in 2023, had faced fierce objection from residents, councillors and MP Wendy Morton.

In addition to the restaurant, McDonald’s plans included 46 car parking spaces, a bike rack for up to 10 bicycles, an outdoor children’s play area, and electric vehicle charging stations.

The fast food giant said the new restaurant would have created 120 full-time and part-time jobs in the area.

The plans were recommended for approval by Walsall Council’s planning officers last year but it was later rejected by planning committee members.

Committee members said the Buffet Island roundabout with six exits is well-known for congestion during peak times.

Councillor Andrew and councillor Mike Bird said the development would cause traffic chaos, but the McDonald’s traffic expert with ‘robust’ data said otherwise.

Other concerns included the restaurant’s proximity to three schools, litter, biodiversity and light pollution, but the main focus was on traffic.

Following the refusal, McDonald’s launched an appeal to the government’s planning inspectorate in January 2025 to try and have it overruled.

The appeal was on the grounds of two of the reasons for refusal.

Firstly, the alleged impact of the development on local health and obesity levels, including proximity to schools and existing takeaway outlets.

Secondly, the sequential test and whether the proposal would adversely affect the vitality and viability of nearby centres.

However, this week, McDonald’s has withdrawn its appeal.

Both McDonald’s and Walsall Council have been approached for statement.